On game days, Lestat Kinney is on the sidelines with the Pirates cheer team. It’s one of the places the local Independence Community College (ICC) student has found his footing on campus.

“Some of my favorite moments at ICC have been on the sidelines at football games with my cheer team,” Lestat said. “I also didn’t expect to get a job on campus when I came here. Between work and cheer, I’ve gotten to know people I probably wouldn’t have met otherwise. That’s what’s made ICC a good fit for me.”

A good fit can mean finding people you connect with on campus and seeing a path toward what you want to do next. That second piece carried much of the weight in TIME and Statista’s inaugural America’s Best Community Colleges 2027 list. ICC was among 250 colleges named to the list, released Nov. 12. The evaluation drew on federal data, including graduation and transfer rates and graduates’ earnings.

Graduation and transfer outcomes and graduate earnings each accounted for 30% of the score. Another 20% weighed how much more graduates earned than people with a high school diploma, relative to the cost of attending. Diversity and campus resources, including student-to-faculty ratios and core spending per student, each made up 10%.

At ICC, support for students working toward graduation or transfer can start with a single assignment. Peer tutors at the Academic Success Center help students work through challenging material in subjects such as math, English and accounting. As students look ahead, eligible students can turn to TRIO Student Support Services for help exploring careers or planning a transfer to a four-year college. The program also provides academic support and serves students who are the first in their families to attend college.

“Our students come to ICC with different goals,” said Taylor Crawshaw, vice president for academic affairs. “Some are the first in their families to go to college. Others are balancing classes with work or family responsibilities. What they have in common is that someone here can help them figure out their next step, whether that’s an instructor who takes time after class or an advisor who helps them make a plan to transfer or start a career. This recognition is a chance to celebrate the persistence of our students and the faculty and staff who show up for them every day.”

To qualify for consideration, colleges had to be public, accredited, financially solvent and classified as associate’s colleges. They also had to offer two-year degree programs, enroll more than 100 students and be located in one of the 50 states or Washington, D.C.

Read TIME’s full list and the selection methodology.